Quality Sepsis Care: ACEP’s Mission, Advocacy and Research in Action


Sama preferred photo

Dr. Sama

By Andrew E. Sama, MD, FACEP

With nearly two-thirds of all admitted septic patients presenting to the ED, and with the clear time sensitivity that exists between recognition, treatment, and outcomes, our members are on the front lines to save lives from this frequently fatal disease. In the CY 2015 IPPS rule, in which CMS cited the fact that “that patients admitted through the ED had a 17% lower likelihood of dying from sepsis than when directly admitted,” CMS finalized NQF #0500: Early Management Bundle for Severe Sepsis and Septic Shock, which mandated the invasive monitoring of CVP and ScVO2 via the placement of a central line in the ED. However, late on Friday, CMS notified hospitals, that it will suspend data collection for the Severe Sepsis and Septic Shock: Management Bundle measure (NQF #0500) until further notice.

Emanuel Rivers, MD, MPH, and his team improved mortality and raised the awareness of the EM community about sepsis through their Early Gold Directed Therapy (EGDT) study in the early 2000s. A few years later, the measure was initially endorsed by the NQF in 2008 without the requirement for a central line for the emergency department. While it is certain that early intervention does reduce mortality, not all elements of the sepsis composite bundle were equally evidence-based.  Many studies over the years have demonstrated dramatic improvements in sepsis-related mortality after the implementation of early interventions for septic patients, which included early antibiotic administration, source control, and aggressive fluid resuscitation without invasive monitoring of CVP and ScVO2. One study addressing this, authored by Dr. Alan Jones and colleagues, was conducted at three EDs in the US, and compared two protocols that both included central venous pressure measurement; however, one used lactate clearance and the other used central venous oxygenation monitoring as a way to guide resuscitation. Dr. Jones’ 2010 study found no differences in mortality, suggesting that using central venous oxygenation to guide resuscitation may not be necessary.

In 2012 the measure underwent routine NQF maintenance review for re-endorsement in 2012-2013.  During those proceedings, under the leadership of David Seaberg, MD, FACEP and myself ACEP commented that central venous pressure (CVP) was not the only reliable measure of intravascular volume. Several members of ACEP’s Quality and Performance Committee (QPC) including chair Jeremiah D. Schuur, MD, MHS, FACEP, Michael Phelan, MD, RDMS, FACEP, Todd Slessinger, MD, FACEP, FCCM, FCCP, Christopher Fee, MD, FACEP, and others testified on conference calls and at in-person meetings, that there were equally effective and less invasive methods for monitoring septic patients.  Nonetheless, the NQF endorsed the requirement for the central line, noting that they would re-consider if additional evidence warranted it.

Within a few months the Protocolized Care for Early Septic Shock (ProCESS) trial was published on March 18, 2014 and under Dr. Alexander Rosenau’s leadership ACEP immediately requested that NQF #0500 undergo an ad hoc review given the impact that this new data would have on this quality measure. After reviewing the data from the ProCESS trial, NQF questioned whether NQF #0500’s item ‘F’, which measures central venous pressure and central venous oxygen saturation, should be retained or removed from the measure. During the review, one of the PIs, Donald Yealy, MD, FACEP engaged in a scientific debate noting that the ProCESS trial enrolled 1,341 patients, with a power to detect a 6-7 percent absolute difference, yet demonstrated no difference in mortality 60-day mortality 90-day mortality, one year mortality, or the need for organ support. The ProCESS also noted no benefit in any outcome when using CVC- guided care and the simpler approaches that stressed early and ongoing care produced the same good outcomes.

CMS, NQF, and others are now also convinced that honing the sepsis bundle is a move forward for our septic patients, with or without invasive monitoring depending on the progression of their disease, their unique circumstances, and the resources available at the ED where they are being treated. As it is ACEP’s mission, we will continue to advocate on behalf of our patients presenting with a diagnosis of sepsis to ensure that they receive the highest quality of emergency care. We look forward to continuing to work with the measure developer to ensure that all septic patients receive the timely, effective care they need, and to continue to save lives from this deadly disease.

Dr. Sama is ACEP’s Immediate Past President and Chair of the Board of Directors

  1. #1 by bestwritingtermpapers.net - September 7th, 2015 at 03:19

    “Emanuel Rivers, MD, MPH, and his team improved mortality and raised the awareness of the EM community about sepsis through their Early Gold Directed Therapy (EGDT) study in the early 2000s. A few years later, the measure was initially endorsed by the NQF in 2008 without the requirement for a central line for the emergency department.”- Thanks DR.Andrew E. Sama for such interesting article. I wish you good luck

  2. #2 by neha - October 19th, 2018 at 00:47

    think you’ll be glad – they do grow so fast. Pretty soon it will be piggy backs, instead of on-the-hip. 🙂

    No, they aren’t able to do band with their full course schedule. At their school, band is a class so they practice during the school day and not after school as a group. One of the boys hasn’t had a study hall all year (even opposite gym because of science lab). I don’t think they miss the practicing part. 🙂 I keep hoping that they’ll pick something up on their own since they know the basics. One of them has a keyboard in his room and he does mess around with that (playing songs from the radio, etc). We had offered to get them private lessons if they wanted to but neither was interested in that. Too much like work! 🙂

  3. #3 by Marina - October 29th, 2018 at 01:49

    Thanks for this great post. Download nova launcher app from: nova launcher prime features apk

  4. #4 by jina - November 22nd, 2018 at 06:43

    I like it because it is so much simple and decent but helpful. Your work is really good,,, I inspired very much from you…Nice and great post. I like your thoughts and I think its best for to everyone… Keep it up and thanks for the information…

  5. #5 by Snap IGFB - December 18th, 2018 at 16:37

    i like your blog and subscribe to it enjoy reading your articles keep sharing good stuff

  6. #6 by Mody Auto Group - January 28th, 2019 at 05:51

    Thanks for sharing wonderful information! It has great tips. You really put lots of efforts into making this article wonderful. Thanks again for sharing.

  7. #8 by Jack Connor - February 21st, 2019 at 01:04

    Great Post! Thanks for sharing with us.
    Belated Birthday Meme

  8. #9 by eve green - March 18th, 2019 at 04:02

    Great post and a great blog! I found a lot of inspiration for my blog,
    and even though they are different there is definitely an overlap, as well.
    You might find some inspiration at mine
    buy Furniture NZ

  9. #10 by Ankur - March 30th, 2019 at 11:15

    This is my first blog site.this is very interesting site also. if you want to more love story ,please visit my website===>>>
    “Exceptional Story”
    This is very romantic Love Story.If you read this story once, you say this again and again…

  10. #11 by Happu Ki Ultan Paltan - June 20th, 2019 at 02:08

    I say thank you for this informative content . really appreciate your hard work I .

  11. #12 by Online Degree - July 18th, 2019 at 07:38

    Online DegreeFind Your All Type Claims Information
    Find Your Legal Case Solicitor.
    Find Insurance Companies.
    Search Rehab and Physio Doctor.
    Find Your Online Short Courses and Degree.
    Find Adviser for Mortgage.
    Find Cheap Auto Insurance.

  12. #13 by buy ebay account - August 5th, 2019 at 00:37

    buy ebay account, ebay account for sale, ebay accounts for sale, ebay stealth account, ebay paypal stealth accounts, ebay stealth account for sale, paypal account for sale, paypal accounts for sale, who buys ebay accounts, we buy ebay accounts, cheap ebay accounts for sale, verified ebay account for sale, buy ebay account with feedback, ebay selling price limit, ebay new seller limits, ebay paypal stealth accounts, ebay stealth, buy ebay stealth, ebay accounts for sale with feedback, cheap ebay accounts for sale

  13. #14 by Temperature & Climate - August 6th, 2019 at 03:37

    Temperature & Climate DataFind Your All Types of Travel Information
    Find Currency Converter.
    Find Temperature & Climate Data.
    Find Driving Distance between cities.
    Find Flight Distance between two destinations.
    Find Major cities around the world.

(will not be published)

  1. No trackbacks yet.